The 9th Public Treasury Court of the Judicial District of São Paulo granted, on 3 November 2026, an injunction in a preventive writ of mandamus (*mandado de segurança*) securing a taxpayer’s right, from 1 January 2027 and for as long as the coexistence of tax regimes governed by Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 lasts, to calculate and pay the municipal services tax (ISS) owed to the Municipality of São Paulo without including in its base the amounts corresponding to the Tax on Goods and Services (IBS) and the Contribution on Goods and Services (CBS), the new consumption taxes created by the 2023 tax reform. The decision ordered the respondent authorities to refrain from issuing assessments, constituting tax credits ex officio, imposing penalties, entering the debt in the federal or municipal debt rolls or the Cadin register, and obstructing the issuance of tax clearance certificates on the sole ground of that non-inclusion.
The dispute is whether IBS and CBS amounts, created by Amendment 132/2023 and governed by Complementary Law No. 214/2025, form part of the “price of the service”, the ISS base under art. 7 of Complementary Law No. 116/2003. The Municipality argued that only a national complementary law may exclude amounts from that base, relying on the Federal Supreme Court’s ADPFs 189 and 190, and that the reform provided express exclusions without including this one. The decision recognised relevant arguments on both sides and found the taxpayer’s position plausible on the basis of the new taxes’ own system of incidence and collection, with specific financial segregation mechanisms, and of the principle of tax legality (Constitution, art. 150, I; National Tax Code, art. 97, IV). It referred, as an interpretive guide, to the thesis in General Repercussion Theme 118, set by the Federal Supreme Court on 21 October 2026 on ISS in the PIS and Cofins base, noting that the precedent concerns the concept of revenue rather than the price of the service, and to a judgment from the same district excluding IBS and CBS from the ICMS base.
What changes in practice: service providers subject to São Paulo ISS now have a first court ruling, on an interim basis, on the composition of the municipal tax base during the transition, which bears on invoicing and tax-calculation settings from January 2027. The municipal tax administration’s position, set out in the information filed in the proceedings, is that the new taxes must form part of the base while the regimes coexist.
The decision is an interim, first-instance ruling with effects limited to the petitioner. The court itself noted that the question is new, without settled case law, and should be resolved after full review, in the judgment; the decision is open to appeal.
By:
Join us on social media.